Criminals or Martyrs? Let the Courts Decide!-British Colonial Legacy in Palestine and the Criminalization of Resistance
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.31430/almuntaqa.1.1.0084الكلمات المفتاحية:
Palestineالملخص
This article takes an example from the volatile history from the Mandate period in Palestine (1919–1948) to show how the political legacy of the colonization of Palestine has formed the basis, in part, of “criminal law” and its use as a tool in this process of the construction of the matrix of colonial rule in Palestine. In the wake of the Buraq/Wailing Wall Revolt in 1929, the British introduced a new legal process in an effort to preserve their control of Palestine and put down Arab resistance to their rule. This article explains how the British constructed a system of laws and legal procedures during their colonial tenure under the Mandate of Palestine that were both reactionary and foundational in all that followed both within the context of British presence in Palestine and in how this relatively short colonial tenure resonated well beyond its historic tenure. By providing a close reading of the British methods and procedures that, at the time, were part of a concerted effort to control a strategic colonial outpost, this article shows how the law was manipulated as a means of control and, subsequently contributed to the ultimate failure of their rule. In an effort to suppress a national movement, the British manipulated their own version of a localized judicial system, creating a criminalizing process that is still used as a major means of control over the indigenous Palestinian Arab population nearly a century later.
المراجع
- See Ghassan Kanafani. Adab al - Muqawamah fi Filastin al - Muhtallah , 1948 - 1966. Beirut: Dar al - Adab , 1966 ; Barbara Harlow , Resistance Literature. Chicago. Her research focuses on the social history of Jerusalem , colonialism , and revolutionary social movements. She can be reached at: rnbarakat @ birzeit. edu. New York: Routledge , 1987.
- Patrick Wolfe , “ Settler Colonialism and the Elimination of the Native ,” Journal of Genocide Research , 2006. For further information about the construction of criminal codes in the colonial and imperial context see: Sally Engle Merry , Colonizing Hawaii: The Cultural Power of Law. Princeton: Princeton University Press , 2000. For a useful example of how colonial justice seeks to preserve order – even an unjust and dysfunctional one see the useful collection regarding colonial law in Australia edited by Dirk Moses: Genocide and settler society: Frontier violence and stolen Indigenous children in Australian history , New
- The “ post - colonial ” context must , of course , be qualified in the case of Palestine / Israel ; though the British rule ended with the end of the Mandate in 1948 ,
- Though Foucault in particular did not thoroughly discuss the colonial context , these authors did. Timothy Mitchell in particular has shown that in order to both capture the mind and body of a colonized population , the colonial government in Egypt used the liberal constructs of modern law to build institutions of governance and control that both organized and consolidated colonial power within a powerful state. See Timothy Mitchell , Colonising Egypt. Berkeley: University of California Press , 1991 and Timothy Mitchell , Rule of Experts: Egypt , Techno - Politics , Modernity. Berkeley: University of California Press , 2002.
- Adalah ’ s Review – Law and Violence. Volume 2 , Summer 2002 , http:// adalah. org / Public / files / English / Publications / Review / 3 / Adalah - Review - V 3 - Summer - 2002 - Law - and - Violence. pdf. Also see Adalah ’ s Review – On Criminization. Volume 5 , Spring 2009 , http:// adalah. org / Public / files / English / Publications /
- See Leslie Sebba. “ The Creation and Evolution of Criminal Law in Colonial and Post - Colonial Societies ,” Crime , History , and Societies 3 , No. 1 (1999), York: Berghahn Books ; 2005. thus ending a direct European colonial involvement , it is still very much a continuing colonial context under Zionist settler - colonial rule in occupied Palestine. Review / 5 / Adalahs - Review - v 5 - Spring 2009 - On - Criminalization. pdf. Accessed 15 August 2013. pages 71 - 91. Though the definition of post - colonial is very much problematic in the context of Palestine and Israel as a continuing colonial situation.
- Nasser Hussain , The Jurisprudence of Emergency: Colonialism and the Rule of Law , Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press , 2003 ; Markus Dirk Dubber , “ The Historical Analysis of Criminal Codes ,” Law and History Review 18 (2000), pages 433 - 440 ; J. J. R. Collingwood , Criminal Law of the East and Central Africa , London: Sweet and Maxwell , 1967 ; Maurice Lang , Codification in the British Empire and America , Amsterdam: H. J. Paris , 1924 ; Radhika Singha , A Despotism of Law: Crime and Justice in Early Colonial India. Delhi: Oxford University Press , 1999 ; Elizabeth Kolsky , “ Codification and the Rule of Colonial Difference: Criminal Procedure in British India ,” Law and History Review 23 , No. 3 (Fall 2005), pages 631 - 683 ; Fazlur Rahman , “ A Survey of Modernization
- The Covenant of the League of Nations re - printed in The Israel - Arab Reader: a Documentary History of the Middle East Conflict , 6 th edition , Walter
- For more on the mandate see for example: Khalidi , The Iron Cage , 2006 ; Matthews , Confronting an Empire , Constructing a Nation , 2006 ; Segev , One
- For a complete analysis of the Buraq Revolt see: Barakat , Rana. “ Thawrat Al Buraq in British Mandate Palestine: Jerusalem , Mass Mobilization and of Muslim Family Law ,” International Journal of Middle East Studies , No. 11 (1980), pages 451 - 465. Laqueur and Barry Rubin , eds. (New York: Penguin Books , 2001), pages 30 - 36. Palestine Complete , 2000 ; Lesch , Arab Politics in Palestine , 1979. Colonial Politics , 1928 - 1930 ,” PhD. Dissertation , University of Chicago , 2007.
- For more on the Wall controversy in particular see: Mattar ,”‘ The Role of the Mufti of Jerusalem ,” June 1983 ; Lundsten “ Wall Politics ,” pp. 3 - 27.
- Norman Bentwich and Helen Bentwich , Mandate memories: 1918 - 1948 (London: Hogarth , 1965) p. 201. regarding criminal , commercial , and procedural processes ; in the case of family law , the law of Palestine ’ s religious communities prevailed. thus manipulating juridical process to further colonial and imperial ends. (see Merry , Colonizing Hawaii.)
- Ottoman Law was a combination of religious Islamic law , and , as a result of late Ottoman reforms , a number of codes inspired by the Napoleonic code
- This process was common in colonial contexts and used “ law ” as part of the civilization mission claiming to bring colonized populations into “ modernity ,”
- For a complete discussion of state courts in the Mandate period see: Likhovski , Law and Identity in Mandate Palestine. pp. 21 - 45.
- Disturbances , Death Sentences , Part I , pages 22 - 35 , The National Archives of the UK / Colonial Office (TNA / CO) 733 / 180 / 6. hearing an appeal from a Court of Assize , but normally the court was composed of five judges (both British and Palestinian). defy logic that a small place like Palestine would have enough British judges to prevent this duplication. [TNA / CO 733 / 180 / 6 , page 25.]
- The criminal procedure laid down by the Trial Upon Information Ordinance in 1924 provided for an appeal to the Supreme Court from any sentence exceeding one year ’ s imprisonment. In the case of a sentence of death , the appeal was automatic. There was not a fixed composition of the Supreme Court
- In the course of the trials , however , this would not be the case. Bentwich argued that to complete the process in a quick and efficient manner , it would
- This report was reproduced in Filastin on October 15 , 1929.
- Ibid. legacy in Palestinian history , Musa al - Alami was one of the prosecuting attorney ’ s during the first phase of the trials in Palestine.
- Ibid. Because the report was produced in Jerusalem , Awni Abd al - Hadi most likely contributed greatly to its production. Abd al - Hadi also later led the defense teams of a majority of the Arab defendants in the initial trials and contributed to their appellate petitions. Ironically , a fellow lawyer with a nationalist
- “ Norman Bentwich ’ s report to the appellate court in London ,” pages 11 - 15. TNA / CO 733 / 180 / 6 / ff 33.
- Norman Bentwich. England in Palestine. London: Kegan Paul , Trench , Trubner , an Co. Ltd , 1932. p. 203.
- The Arab Executive Committee , along with the Mufti and his colleagues , as well as political leaders in various Arab capitals , including Damascus , issued formal statements of complaint about the Chancellor ’ s proclamation.
- Kayyali , Palestine: a Modern History , pp. 148 - 151 ; Kolinsky , Law , Order and Riots pp. 49 - 58 ; Porath , The Emergence of National Movement , pp. 3 - 8.
- “ Williams memo , 4 September 1929 ”. Commission and Inquiry. TNA / CO / 733 / 176 / 2.
- John Chancellor Papers , Rhodes House , Oxford University , Box 11 , file 4 , ff 89 - 90.
- “ Innocents ,” Filastin , September 12 , 1929.
- “ A Path Towards Peace ?” al - Karmil , September 14 , 1929. when the three Arabs were executed , Chancellor later reduced his charges before his appellate process completed. 31 - 63. TNA / CO 733 / 181 / 3.
- The eighth trial of the lone Jewish suspect tried with the result of the death penalty was the case of Yusuf Mizrahi Orfali. While his case was still pending
- Transcript of the Court of Criminal Assize trial of Ahmad Jaber al - Khatib , Aref Tawfiq Ighnaym , and Nayef Tawfiq Ighnaym (October 18 , 1929), pp.
- Ibid., p. 62. Palestine on 2 December.
- This was the one trial that was conducted without multiple defendants originally tried in the Court of Criminal Assize under the ruling of Justices Corrie and Litt who found the defendant guilty of killing with premeditation and sentenced him to death on 5 November 1929 under Article 170 of the Ottoman Penal Code and Section 3 (1)(b) and Section 9 of the Criminal Law Amendment Ordinance No. 2 of 1927. This decision was upheld in the Supreme Court of
- TNA / CO 733 / 180 / 6 , pp. 56 - 61 , from the text of the defense application to the Privy Council.
- Ibid. (composed of Justices Sir Michael McDonnell , FH Baker and R. Copeland). (composed of Senior Puisne Judge , Justice Corrie , and Justices Tute and Copland) on December 5 , 1929. death penalty). (For the petitioners: DN Pritt , Horace Douglas , and Abacarius Bey.) in every stage of this process.
- TNA / CO 733 / 180 / 6 , pages 48 - 51. In the case of Rashid Salim Haj Darwish , Mohammad Salim Zeinab , Fuad Hassan Hijazi , Jamal Salim Khloi , Ali Salim Haj Darwish , Tawfiq Abeid Ahmad , Rashid Mohammad Khartabil , and Ahmed Saleh Kilani vs the Attorney General – convicted of murder with the death penalty on November 29 , 1929 in the Court of Criminal Assize (composed of Justices Corrie and Litt) and upheld in the Supreme Court on February 10 , 1930
- Ibid , pages 69 - 74. In the case of Abdul Jawad Farah and Ata Ahmad al - Zir vs the Attorney General – convicted and given the death penalty by the Criminal Court of Assize (composed of Chief Justice Sir Michael McDonnell and Justice De Freitas) on November 9 , 1929 and upheld by the Supreme Court
- TNA / CO 733 / 180 / 7 , transcript of the proceedings of the Privy Council on March 28 , 1930 , appeals for Ahmed Jabir al - Khatib and others ; Ahmed Mustafa Sherifi and others ; Rashid Salim Haj Darwish and others ; Mustafa Ahmed Deiblis ; Abdul Jawad Farah and another (5 of the 7 cases where Arabs received the
- Ibid. The disconnect with the historic law of the land resembled the arguments over control of the Wall and the proper application of the status quo that dominated the earlier phases of the Buraq Moment. The advocates for the defense argued that the historic rights of the local population were denied to them
- Ibid., pp. 41 - 47. Darwish , Rashid Mohammad Khartabil , Mustafa Ahmad Diblis , Ahmed Mustafa Sherifah. (TNA / CO 733 / 181 / 4.)
- The courts confirmed the rulings for the following Arabs in Hebron: Abd al - Jawad Hussein Farah , Ata Ahmad al - Zir , Isa al - Arafi , Shaker Mahmoud Halwani , Shukri Mahmoud Halwani , Mohammad Khalil Abu Jamjoum , Abbas Nasir al - Din , Abd al - Shakour Sharabati , Abd al - Hafiz Abd al - Nabi Ajuri , Shihdah Awaydah ; and for the following Arabs in Safad: Ahmed Jaber Khatib , Aref Tawfiq Ighnaym , Nayaf Tawfiq Ighnaym , Fuad Hassan Hijazi , Mohammad Abd al - Ghani Hijazi , Tawfiq Obayd Ahmad , Ahmad Salah Killani , Rashid Salim Haj Darwish , Mohammad Salim Zaynab , Jamal Salim Kholi , Ali Salim Haj
- Report of the Commission on the Palestine Disturbances of August , 1929 , Cmd. 3530.
- Letter from Musa Kazim to Passfield , April 19 , 1930 , pp. 52 - 55. TNA / CO 733 / 180 / 7.
- Letter from Passfield to Chancellor , April 17 , 1930 , p. 128. TNA / CO 733 / 180 / 7.
- Chancellor to Passfield , April 5 , 1930 , p. 130. TNA / CO 733 / 180 / 7.
- All the Arabic language newspapers in Palestine were forced closed on June 7 and not permitted to open until after June 23. pieces in the 25 , 26 , and 27 editions of June ’ s paper.
- By describing June 17 th as a historical day for Palestine , Filastin collected accounts from people throughout Palestine and presented their stories in various
- “ Precious Blood and Expendable Blood ,” Filastin , April 8 , 1930. same fate.
- al - Isa commented that while dozens of convicted Arabs were being denied appeals , it was clear to him that none of the Jewish suspects would suffer the
- “ Palestine Day and the Death Penalty ,” Filastin , May 21 , 1930. Mandate administration based on framework established by the Buraq riots.
- Filastin followed progress (or significant lack thereof) of the Arab delegation throughout its stay in London publishing twelve pieces in May that documented the delegation ’ s failures , the British government ’ s unwillingness to amend its policies or change its politics , and the dire need for a new approach towards the
- Filastin , June 4 , 1969.
مقالات مُستشهِدة من مصادر خارجية (3)
- Moheb Zidan (2026) The Political Calculus of Capital Punishment in Mandatory Palestine. https://doi.org/10.1111/hojo.70037
- Itxaso Domínguez de Olazábal (2025) Interwoven Dynamics of Israel and El Salvador as Nodes in a Global Carceral Archipelago Dominated by US Imperialism. https://doi.org/10.1080/19436149.2025.2485692
- Jamal Nabulsi (2023) A politics of conviction: The refusal of colonial carcerality in Palestinian graffiti. https://doi.org/10.1177/19427786231200717
المصادر: Crossref Cited-by، ومراجع مقالات دوريات المركز (الهوامش وقوائم المراجع)
التنزيلات
منشور
إحصاءات الاستخدام
إصدار
القسم
الرخصة
الحقوق الفكرية (c) 2018 المنتقى

هذا العمل مرخص بموجب Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.